Alan Shearer Calls Out Everton’s Ashley Young for Lack of Concentration
Everton’s struggles in the Premier League have been well-documented this season, as the club fights to stay clear of relegation. In their recent match against Aston Villa, the Toffees were once again left frustrated after a series of defensive mistakes undermined their efforts to secure a vital three points. Among the players who came under scrutiny for their lapses in focus was Ashley Young, the veteran full-back who joined Everton in the summer of 2023.
Alan Shearer, one of the Premier League’s greatest ever strikers and a renowned pundit for the BBC, did not hold back when discussing Young’s performance during the game. Shearer, known for his no-nonsense approach to analyzing the game, was quick to point out that Young’s lack of concentration in key moments ultimately cost Everton. While Young’s experience and leadership have been invaluable to Everton in a season full of pressure, Shearer’s criticism was rooted in his belief that the 39-year-old was failing to execute basic defensive duties when it mattered most.
Defensive Mistakes Costing Everton
Throughout the match, which ended in a frustrating draw for Everton, it was clear that Ashley Young’s performance was far from the high standards expected of a player with his wealth of experience. As a full-back, Young’s primary responsibility is to help keep things tight defensively, especially in crucial games that could define Everton’s future in the Premier League. However, his concentration seemed to waver during some key moments, leaving the door open for Aston Villa’s attackers to exploit spaces on the pitch.
In the first half, Young failed to track Villa’s wingers properly, allowing Leon Bailey to slip through and cause havoc in Everton’s defensive third. While Young did attempt to recover, his positioning and decision-making left much to be desired. Shearer, who was commentating on the game, wasted no time in pointing out these mistakes.
“The game is all about concentration, and that’s something Ashley Young needs to work on,” Shearer said during his analysis. “In that situation, you’ve got to be tight and aware of where your opponent is at all times. The space he allowed Villa to exploit was inexcusable, and that’s not the level of concentration Everton need right now, especially in a relegation battle.”
Shearer’s frustration stemmed from the fact that such lapses in focus are typically rare for players of Young’s caliber, and given the importance of the match for Everton, this was a crucial moment in the game. The defensive breakdowns put additional pressure on the Everton attack, which had struggled to break down Villa’s defense throughout the match.
The Mental Game: What Shearer Sees in Young
Alan Shearer’s critique wasn’t simply about Ashley Young’s physical performance or technical ability; it was about the mental aspect of the game. As a player who built his career on being one of the most clinical strikers the Premier League has ever seen, Shearer has a sharp eye for what separates good players from great ones. He was particularly vocal about Young’s inability to stay mentally engaged in key moments of the game.
“I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again—football is just as much about mental concentration as it is about physical ability,” Shearer explained. “Ashley Young has the experience to know that you can’t afford to take your eye off the ball, particularly when the game is on the line. If you switch off for just a moment, you give the opposition the chance to take advantage. And that’s exactly what happened today.”
Shearer’s comments are rooted in the fact that, as an experienced Premier League player, Young should know better. His defensive mistakes weren’t about lacking physical attributes, as he has proven time and time again that he can still compete at the highest level. Rather, it was about his mental concentration in the heat of the moment—something that Shearer believes has been lacking in recent performances.
The Domino Effect of Mental Lapses
The key issue with Young’s lapses in concentration is not just the immediate impact it has on the team but also the domino effect it causes. Everton are already battling to avoid relegation, and every point is crucial. Defensive mistakes like the ones made by Young not only cost goals but also drain confidence and momentum from the entire team.
When Young failed to track the attacking runs of Villa’s wingers, the Everton defense became disorganized, forcing other defenders to cover for his mistakes. This chain reaction ultimately led to Aston Villa’s opening goal, which was directly linked to the defensive errors made by Young. Shearer was quick to call out the failure to stay alert in crucial moments.
“From the moment Young lost his focus, you could see the whole defense start to panic,” Shearer said. “In those situations, the team needs calm heads, and that’s where Young, as a senior player, has to step up. His experience should be ensuring that the team stays organized, but instead, it was the opposite—there was confusion, and Villa took full advantage.”
For Everton, who have been inconsistent this season, this type of defensive fragility is particularly damaging. With relegation looming as a real threat, every mistake counts, and the players can ill afford to let a lack of concentration cost them vital points.
A Call for Leadership from Young
Alan Shearer’s comments also go beyond mere criticism of Young’s individual performance. Shearer pointed out that, as a veteran with years of top-flight experience, Young has a responsibility to lead by example. In a season where Everton is struggling to stay afloat, their senior players, especially those with the experience of Young, need to set the tone for the younger players. Concentration and leadership must be instilled across the squad, especially in high-pressure situations.
“Everton don’t just need Ashley Young to perform individually,” Shearer explained. “They need him to provide leadership. If you’re a senior player, you can’t afford to drop your standards, especially when the team is struggling. Young has been in this situation before, so he knows what needs to be done. He should be using his experience to organize the defense and keep the team focused.”
In many ways, Shearer’s words should serve as a wake-up call for Young. Everton will be looking to him for leadership in the coming weeks, especially with so much on the line. If Young can improve his focus and mental concentration, he has the potential to help guide Everton through their survival battle. However, if the mental lapses persist, it could further hamper Everton’s efforts to stay in the Premier League.
Conclusion: A Key Moment in Young’s Season
Alan Shearer’s call-out of Ashley Young’s lack of concentration is a stark reminder that mental sharpness is just as important as physical ability in the Premier League. For a player of Young’s experience, there is little room for such lapses, especially when the stakes are so high. The question now is whether Young can take this criticism on board and respond positively in Everton’s upcoming matches. If he can refocus and become more mentally engaged in key moments, he could yet play a pivotal role in helping Everton avoid relegation. However, the pressure is mounting, and time is running out for the veteran defender to find his best form.
Leave a Reply